R32 or R410A gas: 5 biggest differences

R32 or R410A gas: 5 biggest differences

Rate this post

For a few years now, the world of heat pumps and air conditioning has been revolutionized by this new gas called R32, replacing R410A. Let's see the differences between these two refrigerant gases and what makes R32 a good candidate to replace R410A.

Here are the main differences between the two gases R32 and R410A:

R32R410A
*PRG 675GWP 2087.5
Pure gasMixture 50% R32 + 50% R125
slightly flammable (A2L)not classified as flammable (A1)
the cheapestmore expensive
slightly more efficientless efficient

*Global warming potential (characterizes the potency of greenhouse gases)

We will see that both have their advantages and disadvantages, but that the European F-Gas regulation has chosen to limit the GWP for the future, just as it had at the time chosen to abandon HCFCs and R22.

1. R410A has a GWP 3 times greater than R32

The GWP of R32 between 550 and 675 is 3 times lower than that of R410 of 2087.5.

The GWP is the global warming potential. By convention it is expressed in "CO2 equivalent", and the GWP of CO2 is 1.

As a reminder, there are 3 types of refrigerant gases:

  • CFCs
  • HCFCs
  • HFCs

It is initially the signature by 65 countries of the Montreal Protocol in 1987, revised in 1990, which signs the abandonment of CFCs very dangerous for the ozone layer. As an example the R11 or R12 which are CFCs and have GWP of 4600, and 10900 🤦♂️. Initially planned for 2000, this ban on CFCs was brought forward to 31.12.1995.

These gases are then replaced by HCFCs, such as R22. They are globally less harmful for the environment, with lower GWP on average. The advantage of HCFCs compared to CFCs is that their ODP is negligible (Ozone Depletion Potential = index that characterizes the potential of wear of the ozone layer). R22 is used in many industrial refrigeration or air conditioning appliances in general.

As of January 1, 2010, HCFCs are banned for use. Machines must be serviced with recycled gas only. And since January 1, 2015 it is forbidden to use or introduce HCFCs, even recycled ones, on the market. No more HCFCs.

This was followed by the advent of HFC fluorinated gases, which have no chlorinated molecules, a lower GWP (except for R410A which has a higher GWP than R22), but especially a zero ODP. These gases are R134A, R410A, or R407C. R410A is in many of the most modern machines still today, but it tends to be replaced by the latest F-Gas darling, R32.

The new European regulation of F-Gas, namely n°517/2014 valid since 01.01.2015 has the ambitious goal of reducing greenhouse gases from 80 to 95% by 2050, compared to 1990 data. The ultimate goal is to limit the global temperature increase on the planet to 2°C max.

Specifically in relation to heat pumps and air conditioners, the ban in this Regulation No. 517/2014 concerns bi-block air conditioning systems that contain less than 3kg of gas with a GWP greater than 750, all by January 1, 2025.

Reversible air conditioners for individual housing are directly targeted because they contain less than 3kg of refrigerant in general. Then various heat pumps on the market will also have to evolve following this ban since some contain less than 3kg of R410A whose GWP is well above 750.

As an example, here is the refrigerant charge of some well-known heat pump references:

Heat pump modelFluid typeFluid load (kg)
Daikin Altherma 3 H HTR324.2
AQUAREA HIGH PERFORMANCE
ALL IN ONE" DUO
R410A1.2 à 2.55
NIBE F2120-8 to 20R410A2.4 à 3
Alfea Extensa Duo 5 to 10R410A1.1 à 1.8
Alfea Extensa Duo 5 to 10R320.97 à 1.63

2. R410A is a mixture while R32 is pure

In fact, R32 is already present in R410A which is a mixture between R32 itself at 50% and R125 at 50%. R32 has the same toxicity class as R410A: it is classified as low toxicity.

3. R32 is slightly flammable, not R410A

A disadvantage of R32 compared to R410A is its flammability and toxicity class according to the NIOSH. Indeed, R32 is classified as A2L which means that it is not very toxic but slightly flammable.

source : https://www.lennoxemea.com/fr/a2l-2/


This is not great news as it is planned to be installed in individual housing or ERP.

However, following a modification of article CH 35 of the order of June 25, 1980 by the order of May 10, 2019, it is possible for ERP of cat. 1 to cat. 4 to use flammable fluids provided that a certain number of measures are implemented to control the risk.

source https://entreprendre.service-public.fr/vosdroits/F32351

4. R32 is cheaper than R410A

R32 is available on the market at prices about 20% lower than R410A.

from a dozen kg, in cylinder, R32 costs 20€ / kg, while R410A costs rather 25€ / kg

Here is the example on an online shop : refrigerantboys.com

source : https://www.refrigerantboys.com/
source : https://www.refrigerantboys.com/

5. For the same power, R32 is more efficient

According to a study conducted by the Center for Environmental Energy Engineering, University of Maryland, USA, and published in 2013The use of R32 in a thermodynamic cycle shows a power of 10% higher and a COP of 9% higher compared to the same cycle with R410A.

R32 is therefore an excellent candidate to replace R410A in air conditioning and heat pump applications

R290: the other natural refrigerant gas that replaces R410A

We talk a lot about R32 which, it is true, is already present in many new generation heat pumps for several brands, including Daikin or Atlantic, but other brands such as NIBE the Swedish or Vaillant the German, but also Wolf or Dimplex, have chosen an even cleaner gas. It is a gas that we know well, since it is the R290 also known as propane.

Very used in cylinders to feed a stove for example, it is a liquefied petroleum gas very resistant to cold, but especially much less harmful for the ozone layer than HFCs since its GWP or PRG is 3 and its ODP is 0. NIBE, Vaillant, Wolf and Dimplex, all European, are thus making the choice in favor of the environment, but there is a but.

Indeed, this very interesting gas from an ecological point of view (and economically since it is worth at the writing of this article less than 2€ per kg), is unfortunately even more flammable than R32, since it is classified A3, i.e. highly flammable according to the NIOSH standard quoted above, and thus requires to take more precautions.

Characteristics of natural refrigerant gas R290 or propane

There is also Stiebel Eltron, the great German heat pump specialist, which has decided to use R454C for its HPAs since 01.01.2021. This gas has a GWP of 148, and excellent thermodynamic properties allowing like R290 to make high temperature up to 75°C.

Conclusion

R32, as a new generation HFC, has many advantages that justify its use to replace R410A. Its major disadvantage lies in its flammability, obliging equipment manufacturers to implement reinforced protective measures to avoid any fire and any disaster that could result from it. Japanese and French manufacturers have opted for R32.

However, the European side prefers R290 or propane because it is more environmentally friendly, but also more flammable. Its thermodynamic properties are very good and are close to those of the very widespread gas that was R22 in its time: what pleases the manufacturers.

Research is constantly progressing, and new gases are already being studied, which could prove to be better than R32 or R290, but this has yet to be confirmed. These include DR-55 and DR-5A gases which are HFO HFC blends. These two would present similar performances to the base gas R410A and would have a much lower environmental impact. In fact the possible smooth candidates that are studied to replace the HFC R410A are on this picture below, but for the moment the two most serious seem to be the DR55 and DR5A. Well this DR55 is not so new since it was revealed by the Chemours company in 2015 at the Yokohama summit. But this study has seriously evaluated the possibility of it replacing R410A and being a rival to R32.

en_USEnglish